
Recently I read an article by the late Dr. Robert Delnay that first appeared in Faith Baptist Theological Seminary’s July/August 1999 issue. Dr DeInay became the founding dean of Faith Baptist Seminary, in Iowa, in 1986, and he was an eminent professor of history and homiletics at Faith and other institutions for decades. I was privileged to take some of his courses at Central Baptist Seminary in Minneapolis in the 1960s.
In the article, he described what preaching at the turn of the then-new millennium had become. Here are some of his observations, which are even more relevant today:
“Those who have listened to preaching for a least a generation are likely to observe that it is not what it once was. On the basis of both anecdote and memory, it is on balance neither as interesting nor as compelling as it was within living memory. Furthermore, the results are not the same. First-time adult decisions for salvation used to be relatively common in many churches every Sunday. Now (1999) such decisions have to be programmed, usually after inducing people to make decisions in their own homes, and then persuading them to come to church to go forward.
There are several ways to account for the difference. First, it may be the faulty memory of the middle-aged, as they think of the good old days. Or it may be that homiletics courses are not as helpful as they used to be. Or that young preachers do not hear the able and earnest models that once were common.
While any of these may have some validity, I suspect that a major reason for the change lies somewhere else. It is that in the First Baptist Church of Laodicea the pastor has different intellectual resources that he draws on, and some of these resources are less than helpful.”
Dr. Delnay continued by suggesting some factors that have contributed to the differences in contemporary preaching versus what he remembered from the “good old days.”
“The Decline of Reading. The chain of bookstores offer quiet and coffee to their customers. The publishers are pouring out such a torrent of books that most go out of print in six months…But those matters do not assure that many preachers are reading books. Spurgeon was reputed to read three or four heavy books a week. By 1950, Howard Sugden owned a library of about 5,000 volumes, and he estimated that he had read about half of it, including the commentaries. His conference ministry is still legendary today.
However, when it comes to the use of books and study tools, my impression is that they are being used less and less. A pastor told me that he did not have time to read books, probably not one a year, and others give evidence of the same pattern.
Some pastors may object that they have the marvelous resources of their computer program, with five translations of the Bible, complete commentaries, and perhaps even the texts in their original languages. Their objection sounds pretty impressive, but I believe it could be shown that few of those programs produce Bible expositors, and few expositors make much use of those fabulous tools. I feel that the screen has proven to be a poor substitute for the printed page. It is a good medium for conveying information and data, but not for generating wisdom. It seems more than coincidence that the screen has become more common just at the time when earnest exposition has become scarce.
The Orientation Toward Entertainment. We now have a whole culture geared toward near-constant entertainment. To about World War I, about the only common diversions were vaudeville and the preacher, with maybe summer concerts by the town band. During the second quarter of this century the movies became available, but hardly for the saints. At mid-century the tube invaded the living room, attracting a viewing audience for about thirty to thirty-five hours a week. A broken TV set caused a near-panic in the family, because the medium became highly addictive. As the video reached the total population (practically nobody had it in 1947; almost everybody had it by 1952) it made its impact on preaching. More and more the TV seemed to provide the major intellectual resource that preachers drew on. Sports and the news took up the time that otherwise would have gone into books and periodicals. A notable preacher told me that he liked to go home after church and watch a movie, it helped him to relax. Twenty years before that he would not go near a movie theater; now his private life was nobody’s business. Meanwhile, his mental resources were withering, and the number of preachers going through the same change was legion.
The move to near-constant entertainment coincided with other trends. Preaching dealt less with the message of the cross and more with the concern for good self-image. The programs, games and adds provided few spiritual and sermonic insights. As the well dried up, I was astonished to hear my former students preaching as sermon illustrations the scenes they had seen in movies. Those trends coincided with the decline in pulpit evangelism, and little wonder. Those trends also coincided with a love for the world that would have driven other generations to their knees. Can anyone affirm that the saints are less materialistic than they were a generation ago? Can anyone deny a cause and effect pattern here?
So now the wave of the future is to gear the whole program of the church to entertainment. The world provided the means to draw people to Christ, and the big churches got bigger by offering experience and amusement. Worship leaders have replaced worship.”
Well, these warnings by Dr. Delnay—issued more than a quarter of a century ago—now seem prophetic. We have seen his concerns come to full bloom, even in what are known as “fundamental, Bible-preaching churches.” For sure, technology and “the screen” have immense potential for good; but for today’s preachers—and for all believers, really—they might well come with the warning: “These tools should never be considered a replacement for the Book, God’s Word.” Selah.
“This book of the law shall not depart out of thy mouth; but thou shalt meditate therein day and night, that thou mayest observe to do according to all that is written therein: for then thou shalt make thy way prosperous, and then thou shalt have good success.” (Joshua 1:8)








